Home

   Archive


   Links


   Contact Us


   Webmaster


 
 
Death in the East: The Müller Reports

 

The subject of the killing, or alleged killing, of Jews in captured Soviet territory by German security units in the 1940s has become a very heated, albeit a very limited, one. On the one side, a small group of historical revisionists claim that accounts of these killings are simply lies propagated by radical Jewish groups for self-aggrandizement  and on the other, a much larger and very vocal group that states that over six millions of Jews were slaughtered by the Germans.  The discovery of official German reports in the U.S. National Archives disclosed that the truth is hardly palatable to either side.

The Official German RSHA Daily Reports on the Action of all Einsatzgruppen engaged in Anti-Partisan Warfare on the Eastern Front 23 June 1941 through 21 May 1943 inclusive

The information in the following tables comes directly from twelve folders of IV A 1 Lagezimmer and are the only surviving originals of Ereignismeldung UdSSR. Numbers 1-195 from 23. June 1941 through 24 April 1942 by CdS/Amt IV A1 and Meldungen aus den besetzeten Ostgebeiten, Numbers 1-55 between 1 May 1942 and 31 May 1943 by CdS Kommando stab. Copies of these important documents can be found in the U.S. National Archives, Rolls T-175 No’s 233 through 236, the Berlin Document center in Berlin and the Institut für Zeitgeschichte in Munich. These important historical records are available to the public at approximately $30.00 per roll. The total number of secret reports runs to slightly over 4,000 pages.

With the invasion of Soviet Russia on 21 June 1941, Reinhard Heydrich, Chief of the RSHA instituted these reports into a comprehensive daily summery of the various daily reports submitted by the Einsatzgruppen and Einsatzkommandos.Sammelmeldung UdSSR, Nr. 1” was prepared by SS-Gruppenführer Heinrich Müller, head of Amt IV, the Gestapo. They were classified as “Geheime Reichssache” or Secret State matters and circulated to a limited distribution list (at first 10 copies, then distribution was expanded successively.)  Following the end of World War II, Müller, using the name of Schwarzer, fled to Switzerland where he worked for Swiss intelligence until hired by the CIA’s James Critchfield in 1948.[See recently declassified Müller CIA files at NARA for further information]

The only known copies of these daily summaries was from the IV A 1 Lagezimmer. A typical; Ereignismeldung contains a list of Standorte of each HSSPF, KdS, Einsatzgruppe, Einsatzkommando, and Sonderkommando reporting, accounts of Bandenbekämpfung operations, including the shooting of Jews and Soviet Political Commissars, and reports on political and economic conditions much like those to be found in standard SD reports.

Since a great deal of fictional data has been presented concerning the number of Jews who died as a result of interactions with the Einsatzgruppen and their subgroups, it is instructive to study all of these daily, highly classified reports, and set down the actual numbers of the casualties on the Soviet Russian side. It is clearly obvious from reading through these over 4,000 pages of detailed reports that Jews were singled out for murder both because they were Jews but also because they were basically allied with the Soviet Partisan movement and were killed in combat with German security units.

It should be noted that these Müller reports were classified as highly secret and had a very limited circulation within the organs of the Third Reich. As Müller was noted for his accuracy and thoroughness, it is not possible that he invented these figures in the event that future scholars would be mislead by their contents

Very often numbers of Communist party officials and the dreaded Commissars were executed by the SD units when they were captured. As there were a significant number of Jews in these organs, it has been impossible to differentiate between the makeup of the totals. The reports of executions were, in a number of cases, marked: Execution of Communist officials and Jews.

The following examples of messages are from the Einsatzgruppen Reports.

The number of the report and the date is noted with each excerpt. The Einsatzgruppen reported on their activities to their respective headquarters which sent the information to Berlin. There the RSHA compiled concise reports in the name of the Chief of Sipo and the SD. Copies were distributed to high- ranking army, police and SS officers, diplomats, members of the foreign office an even to industrialists as they related to economic factors in the Soviet territories.  The Einsatzgruppen Reports were discovered by the U.S. Army in Gestapo headquarters in Berlin after the war. They were initially impounded by a research analyst attached to the Berlin branch of the Office of the Chief of Council for War Crimes. They were sealed and transported in the custody of the US Army to Nuremberg. During the first days of the Einsatzgruppen Trial, the authenticity of the reports was established beyond doubt and none of the German defendants challenged their validity.

After the trial, the original reports were sent to the National Archives [NARA] in Washington, DC. In 1960 they were given to the Bundesarchiv in Koblenz. Photocopies of all the reports remain in the National Archives.

Examples of the Einsatzgruppen Reports

Operational Situation Report USSR No. 17
7.July.1941

According to instructions by RSHA, liquidations of government and party officials, in all named cities of Byelorussia, were carried out. Concerning the Jews, according to orders, the same policy was adopted. The exact number of the liquidated has not as yet been established.

Operational Situation Report USSR No. 19
11.July.1941

In Kaunas, up to now a total of 7,800 Jews have been liquidated, partly through pogroms and partly through shooting by Lithuanian Kommandos. All of the corpses have been removed. Further mass shootings are no longer possible.  Therefore, I summoned a Jewish committee and explained that up to now we had no reason to interfere with the internal arrangements between the Lithuanians and the Jews.

Operational Situation Report USSR No. 106
7.October.1941

In agreement with the city military command, all the Jews of Kiev were ordered to appear at a certain place on Monday, 29 September, by 6 o'clock. This order was publicized by posters all over the town by members of the newly organized Ukrainian militia. At the same time, oral information was passed that all the Jews of Kiev would be moved to another place. In cooperations with the HQ of the Einsatzgruppen and two Kommandos of  Police Regiment South, Sonderkommando 4a executed 33,771 Jews on September 29 and 30.

[NOTE: This took place outside of Kiev and is known, post-war as the so-called Babi Yar massacre. .Much has been made by post-war writers, about this incident. There is absolutely nothing in any of the official German reports that indicate where they executed the Jews of Kiev. Post-war, it was suggested that this took place at the Babi Yar ravine west of Kiev because that is the area in which Stalin’s NKVD shot its own victims so post-war investigations of this area, which disclosed no Jewish remains, were looking in the wrong place for a burial ground]

Operational Situation Report USSR No. 111
12.October.1941

These were the reasons for the executions carried out by the Kommandos: political officials; plundereres and saboteurs; active Communists and political representatives; Jews who gained their release from prison camps by false statements; agents and informers of the NKVD; persons who by false depositions and witness influencing were instrumental in the deportation of ethnic Germans; Jewish sadism and revenge; undesirable elements; partisans; politruks; danger of plague and epidemics; members of Russian bands; armed  insurgents supplying Russian bands; rebels and agitators; drifting juveniles; Jews in general.

Operational Situation Report USSR No. 117
18.October.1941

The districts occupied by the Kommandos were cleansed of Jews. 4,091 Jews and 46 Communists were executed during the time span covered by the report, bringing the total to 40,699 [for the period of 1-15 October 1941 by Einsatzgruppen D].

Operational Situation Report USSR No. 126
27.October.1941

The difficulties in carrying out such a large action - first of all with respect to sowing disunity - were overcome in Kiev by a call via posters to the Jewish population that they were to move. Although at the start, one could count on the participation of about 5,000-6,000 Jews, more than 30,000 Jews turned up who, due to extraordinarily skillful organization, believed in the transfer right up to the moment of their execution.

Thus, even if about 75,000 Jews had been liquidated so far, it has already become clear that a solution of the Jewish question will not be possible in this way. True, we have succeeded in bringing about a total solution to the Jewish problem, particularly in smaller towns and also in the villages.  However, in bigger towns it was observed that all the Jews have disappeared after such an execution.

Operational Situation Report USSR No.127
31.Oct.1941

In this area the Security Police has come up against two major groups of adversaries. They are: 1) the Jews, 2) those once active in the former Soviet regime ... In this regard it should be pointed out that in the Ukraine, those who sympathized with the Soviets were predominantly Jews ... It can now be stated without reservation that the Jews were, without exception, supporters of Bolshevism. "Over and over again, particularly in the cities, the Jews are cited as the real Soviet rulers who exploited the people with  indescribable brutality and delivered them to their deaths at the hands of the NKVD. The (German Security Police) units have carried out approximately 10,000 interrogations during the past four months. Again and again, the Jews were cited as having worked actively for the Soviets, if not in responsible positions then at least as agents, collaborators or informers. Not a single Jewish corpse had been found in any of the numerous mass graves. In any case, it is evident that  the Jews share the greatest guilt with others for the slaughter of the Ukrainian people and the ethnic Germans.

For this reason, special measures against the Jews are considered necessary by the Security Police  

Operational Situation Report USSR No. 173
25.February.1942

In the course of a routine Security Police screening of an additional part of the civilian population around Leningrad, 140 more people had to be shot. The reasons for this were as follows:

a)   Active participation in the Communist Party before the arrival of the German troops;

b)   Seditious and provocative activity since the arrival of the German Army;

c)   Partisan activity;

d)   Espionage;

e)   Belonging to the Jewish race. “

The Einsatzgruppen were part of the SS. They were created at the direction of Hitler and Himmler by Heydrich the Chief of the Security Police and SD, who was Himmler's right hand man, and operated under the direct control of the RSHA, the Reich Security Main Office, one of the most important of the twelve main offices of the SS.

These units were considered para-military police units are were initially used to maintain internal order in acquired new territories, round up known enemies of the Reich and assist the military in rear area security.

The Einsatzgruppen were formed in the spring of 1938 with the incorporation of the German-speaking Sudetenland into the German Reich. They were also used in Austria and, after the outbreak of World War II in September, 1939, in conquered Polish territory

In anticipation of the assault on Russia, Hitler issued an order directing that the Security Police and the Security Service be called in to assist the army in breaking every means of resistance behind the fighting front. Thereafter, the Quartermaster General of the Army, General Wagner, representing Keitel, the Chief of the Supreme Command of the Wehrmacht, met Heydrich, Chief of the Security Police and Security Service. These two men reached an agreement concerning the activation, commitment, command, and jurisdiction of units of the Security Police and SD within the framework of the army. The Einsatzgruppen were to function in the rear operational areas in administrative subordination to the field armies, in order to carry out these tasks as directed by Heydrich and Himmler.

The normal strength of the Einsatzgruppen was from 600 to 800 men. The officer strength of the Einsatzgruppen was drawn from the SD, SS, Criminal Police (Kripo) and Gestapo. The enlisted forces were composed of the Waffen SS, the regular police, the Gestapo, and locally-recruited police. When occasion demanded, the Wehrmacht commanders would bolster the strength of the Einsatzgruppen with contingents of their own. The Einsatzgruppen were divided into Einsatzkommandos and Sonderkornmandos.

These subunits differed only in name. When a mission called for a very small task force, the Einsatz or Sonderkommandos were capable of further subdivision, called Teilkommando or splinter groups.

The activity of the Einsatzgruppen was not limited to the civilian population alone, but reached into prisoner-of-war camps. Captured Soviet soldiers were screened by Einsatzkommandos personnel in order to find and execute Soviet political commissars

The Einsatzgruppen were German special duty squads, composed primarily of SS and police personnel. The commanders and officers were also members of the Security Police and the Security Service. The units were directly subordinate to the Reich Security Main Office (Reichssicherheitshauptamt or RSHA) in Berlin and were to operate regionally in coordination with higher SS and police leaders. Ordered to follow the German army into the Soviet Union, the Einsatzgruppen were dependent upon the army for supplies and logistical support.

The chief of the RSHA, Reinhard Heydrich, instructed the Einsatzgruppe commanders to support Wehrmacht units in the rear areas of operation who were engaged in a growing partisan movement behind the front lines. These partisan groups were generally comprised of Russian civilians, Soviet military members and officials of the Soviet Communist Party and state apparatus.

As the German army advanced deep into Soviet territory, the Einsatzgruppen followed the troops. Supported by locally recruited police auxiliaries and other SS and German police units, the Einsatzgruppe personnel at first merely did police work behind the lines. In late July 1941, after the deployment of larger units of SS and police personnel in the occupied Soviet Union, these units, including the Einsatzgruppen, began more independent but still coordinated anti-partisan activities.

Four battalion-sized Einsatzgruppen and several police battalions were deployed in the occupied Soviet Union.

Einsatzgruppe A fanned out from East Prussia across Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia toward Leningrad. Its members were active in Kovno, Riga, and Vilna.

Einsatzgruppe A and the units under its command rounded up and executed a significant number of Russians, to include Communist functionaries.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 15 October 1941 in Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, and White Ruthenia, Einsatzgruppe A executed 118,430 Jews and 3,398 Communists.

On or about 4 July 1941 in the city of Riga, Sonderkommando la and Einsatzkommando 2, together with auxiliary police under their command, carried out pogroms in which all synagogues were destroyed and 400 Jews were executed.

During October 1941 in Estonia, Einsatzkommando la, together with Estonian units under their command, committed numerous executions pursuant to a program for the extermination of all Jewish males over sixteen except doctors and Jewish elders.

During the period 7 November 1941 to 11 November 1941 in Minsk, Sonderkommando1b executed 6,624 Jews.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 16 January 1942 in its operational areas, Einsatzkommando 2 executed 33,970 persons.

On 30 November 1941 in Riga, 20 men of Einsatzkommando 2 participated in the execution of 10,600 Jews.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 19 September 1941 in Lithuania, Einsatzkommando 3 executed 692 persons.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 10 August 1941 in the area of Kovno [Kaunas] and Riga, Einsatzgruppe A executed 29,000 persons.

During the period 2 October 1941 to 10 October 1941 in the vicinity of Krasnogvardeisk, Einsatzgruppe A executed 260 persons.

During the period 15 October 1941 to 23 October 1941 in the vicinity of Krasnogvardeisk, Einsatzgruppe A executed 156 persons.

During the period 24 October 1941 to 5 November 1941 in the vicinity of Krasnogvardeisk, Einsatzgruppe A executed 118 persons.

On 20 November 1941 in the vicinity of Krasnogvardeisk, Einsatzgruppe A executed 855 persons.

In about December 1941 in the ghetto in Vitebsk, units of Einsatzgruppe A executed 4,090 Jews.

On 22 December 1941 in Vilnyus [Vilna] , units of Einsatzgruppe A executed 402 persons including 385 Jews.

On 1 February 1942 in Loknya, units of Einsatzgruppe A executed the 38 gypsies and Jews remaining there.

On 2 and 3 March 1942 in Minsk, units of Einsatzgruppe A executed 3,412 Jews.

On 2 and 3 March 1942 in Baranovichi, units of Einsatzgruppe A executed 2,007 Jews.

On 17 March 1942 in Ilya, east of Vileika, units of Einsatzgruppe A executed 520 Jews.

On or about 7 April 1942 in Kovno and Olita, Lithuania, units of Einsatzgruppe A executed 44 persons.

During the period 10 April 1942 to 24 April 1942 in Latvia, units of Einsatzgruppe A executed 1,272 persons, including 983 Jews, 204 Communists and 71 gypsies.

Totals: 217,560 executed including 147,451 Jews

Einsatzgruppe B set out from Warsaw in occupied Poland, and moved east through Belorussia towards Smolensk. Its members operated in Grodno, Minsk, Brest-Litovsk, Slonim, Gomel, and Mogilev, among other places.

In about July 1941 in the city of Minsk, units of Einsatzgruppe B executed 1,050 Jews, political officials, "Asiatics" and others.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 14 November 1941 in the vicinity of Minsk and Smolensk, Einsatzgruppe B executed  45,467 persons.

On 15 October 1941 in Mogilev, units of Einsatzgruppe B executed 83 "Asiatics."

On 19 October 1941 in Mogilev, units of Einsatzgruppe B participated in the execution of 3,726 Jews.

On 23 October 1941 in the vicinity of Mogilev, units of Einsatzgruppe B executed 279 Jews.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 14 November 1941 in its operational areas, Sonderkommando 7a executed 1,517 persons.

In September or October 1941 in Sadrudubs, Sonderkommando 7a executed 272 Jews.

During the period 6 March 1942 to 30 March 1942 in the vicinity of Klintsy, Sonderkommando 7a executed 1,585 Jews and 45 gypsies.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 14 November 1941 in its operational areas, Sonderkommando 7b executed 1,822 persons.

During the period from September to October 1941 in Rechitsa, White Ruthenia, Sonderkommando 7b executed 216 Jews.

During the period 6 March 1942 to 30 March 1942 in the vicinity of Bryansk, Sonderkommando 7b executed 82 persons, including 27 Jews.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 14 November 1941 in its operational areas, Einsatzkommando 8 executed 28,219 persons.

In September or October 1941 in the area of Shklov, Einsatzkommando 8 executed 627 Jews and 812 other persons.

In September or October 1941 in Mogilev, Einsatzkommando 8 participated in the execution of 113 Jews.

In September or October 1941 in Krupka, Einsatzkommando 8 executed 912 Jews.

In September or October 1941 in Sholopaniche, Einsatzkommando 8 executed 822 Jews.

During the period 6 March 1942 to 30 March 1942 in the vicinity of Mogilev, Einsatzkommando 8 executed 1,609 persons, including 1,551 Jews and 33 gypsies.

On 8 October 1941 in the ghetto of Vitebsk, Einsatzkommando 9 began executing Jews and by 25 October 1941, 3,000 Jews had been executed.

During the period 6 March 1942 to 30 March 1942 in the vicinity of Vitebsk, Einsatzkommando 9 a executed 273 persons, including 170 Jews.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 14 November 1941 in its operational areas, the group staff of Einsatzgruppe B and the Vorkommando Moscow executed 2,457 persons.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 20 August 1941 in the vicinity of Smolensk, the group staff of Einsatzgruppe B and the Vorkommando Moscow executed 144 persons.

In September or October 1941 in Tatarsk, the group staff of Einsatzgruppe B and the Vorkommando Moscow executed all male Jews.

During the period 6 March to 30 March 1942 in the vicinity of Roslavl, Vorkommando Moscow executed 52 persons.

During the period 6 March 1942 to 30 March 1942 in the vicinity of Smolensk, Trupp Smolensk executed 60 persons, including 18 Jews.

Totals: 95,244 executed including 12,406 Jews

Einsatzgruppe C began operations from the Krakow area and headed across the Ukraine    towards Kiev and Donetsk, in the areas of Lvov, Tarnopol, Zolochev, Kremenets, Kharkov, and Kiev.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 3 November 1941 in the vicinity of Zhitomir, Novo Ukrainka and Kiev, Einsatzgruppe C executed more than 75,000 Jews.

On 19 September 1941 in Zhitomir, Einsatzgruppe C executed 3,145 Jews and confiscated their clothing and valuables.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 29 July 1941 in the vicinity of Zhitomir, Sonderkommando 4a executed 2,531 persons.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 12 October 1941 in its operational areas, Sonderkommando 4a executed more than 51,000 persons.

During the period from 2'7 June to 29 June 1941 in the vicinity of Sokal and Lutsk, Sonderkommando 4a executed 300 Jews and 317 Communists.

In July or August 1941 in Fastov, Sonderkommando 4a executed all the Jews between the ages of 12 and 60.

In September or October 1941 in the vicinity of Vyrna and Dederev, Sonderkommando 4a executed 32 gypsies.

On 29 and 30 September 1941 in Kiev, Einsatzkommando 4a, together with the group staff and police units, executed 33,771 Jews and confiscated their clothing and valuables.

On 8 October 1941 in Jagotin, Sonderkommando executed 126 Jews.

On 23 November 1941 in Poltava, Sonderkommando executed 1,638 Jews.

In about July 1941 in Tarnopol, Sonderkommando executed 180 Jews.

During the period from 13 September to 26 September 1941 in the vicinity of Kremenchug, Sonderkommando 4b executed 125 Jews and 103 political officials.

During the period 4 October 1941 to 10 October 1941 in Poltava, Sonderkommando 4b executed 186 persons.

From about 11 October 1941 to 30 October 1941 in the vicinity of Poltava, Sonderkommando 4b executed 595 persons.

During the period 14 January 1942 to 12 February 1942 in the vicinity of Kiev, Sonderkommando 4b executed 861 persons, including 139 Jews and 649 political officials.

During the period from February 1942 to March 1942 in the vicinity of Artemovsk, Sonderkommando 4b executed 1,317 persons, including 1,224 Jews and 63 "political activists."

During the period from 22 June 1941 to 10 November 1941 in its operational areas, Einsatzkommando 5 executed 29,644 persons.

During July or August 1941 in Berdichev, Einsatzkommando 5 executed 74 Jews.

During the period 7 September 1941 to 5 October 1941 in the vicinity of Berdichev, Einsatzkommando 5 executed 8,800 Jews and 207 political officials.

On 22 and 23 September 1941 in Uman, Einsatzkommando 5 executed 1,412 Jews.

During the period 20 October 1941 to 26 October 1941 in the vicinity of Kiev, Einsatzkommando 5 executed 4,372 Jews and 36 political officials.

During the period from 23 November 1941 to 30 November 1941 in the vicinity of Rovno, Einsatzkommando executed 2,615 Jews and 64 political officials.

During the period from 12 January 1942 to 24 January 1942 in the vicinity of Kiev, Einsatzkommando 5 executed about 8,000 Jews and 104 political officials.

During the period from 24 November 1941 to 30 November 1941 in the vicinity of Dnepropetrovsk, Einsatzkommando 6 executed 226 Jews and 19 political officials.

From about 10 January 1942 to 6 February 1942 in the vicinity of Stalino, Einsatzkommando 6 executed about 149 Jews and 173 political officials.

In about February 1942 in the vicinity of Stalino, Einsatzkommando 6 executed 493 persons, including 80 "political activists" and 369 Jews.

Totals: 216,860 executed including 141,101 Jews

Einsatzgruppe D operated in southern Ukraine, operating in the areas of Nikolayev, Kherson, Simferopol, Sevastopol, and Feodosiya 

During the period from 22 June 1941 to July 1943, Einsatzgruppe D, in the area of southern Russia, executed more than 90,000 persons.

On 15 July 1941 in the vicinity of Beltsy, Sonderkommando 10a executed 45 persons, including the Counsel of Jewish Elders.

In July 1941 in the vicinity of Chernovitsy, Sonderkommando 10b executed 16 Communists and 682 Jews.

During the period 22 June 1941 to 7 August 1941 in the vicinity of Kichinev, Einsatzkommando lla executed 551 Jews.

In about July 1941 in Tighina, Einsatzkommando llb executed 151 Jews.

In about December 1941 in the vicinity of Simferopol, Einsatzkommando l1b executed over 700 persons.

During the period from 22 June 1941 to 23 August 1941 in Babchinzy, Einsatzkommando 12 executed 94 Jews.

During the period 15 July 1941 to 30 July 1941 in the vicinity of Khotin, Einsatzgruppe D executed 150 Jews and Communists.

During the period 19 August 1941 to 15 September 1941 in the vicinity of Nikolaev, Einsatzgruppe D executed 8,890 Jews and Communists.

During the period 16 September 1941 to 30 September 1941 in the vicinity of Nikolacv and Kherson, Einsatzgruppe D executed 22,467 Jews.

During the period 1 October 1941 to 15 October 1941 in the area east of the Dnepr, Einsatzgruppe D executed 4,891 Jews and 46 Communists.

During the period 15 January 1942 to 31 January 1942 within its operational areas, Einsatzgruppe D executed 3,601 persons, including 3,286 Jews and 152 Communists.

During the period 1 February 1942 to 15 February 1942 20 10 within its operational areas, Einsatzgruppe D executed 1, 451 persons, including 920 Jews and 468 Communists.

During the period 16 February 1942 to 28 February 1942 within its operational areas, Einsatzgruppe D executed 1,515 persons, including 729 Jews, 271 Communists and 421 gypsies and other persons.

During the period 1 March 1942 to 15 March 1942 within its operational areas, Einsatzgruppe D executed 2,010 persons, including 678 Jews, 359 Communists, and 810 gypsies and other persons.

During the period 15 March 1942 to 30 March 1942 within its operational areas, Einsatzgruppe D executed 1,501 persons, including 588 Jews, 405 Communists, and 261 gypsies and other persons.

Totals 133,824 executed including 35,034 Jews

Grand total: 663,488 executed including 335,993 Jews

(Including total deaths in Lithuania of 137,346) *

800,834 total recorded 1941-1943 Einsatzgruppen executions in the Eastern areas

*(Figures to be shown in a later edition )