|
The Voice of the
White House
Washington, D.C.,
April 10, 2008: “The CIA has never done anything right and
its blunders have been very costly in human life and destructive to
anything or anyone who gets in the way of what their idiotic leaders
believe is in their own, not the nation’s, interest.
As a case in point,
here is an overview (if I printed this verbatim, they would turn
this place upside down to find and prosecute me) of the CIA’s
meddling in Chinese affairs, both actual and projected.
Know that no one
controls the CIA. For many years, they controlled us in that they
had strong connections with corporate media and the top levels of
the government. They could do as they liked.
A friend of some
deputy director was having his overseas properties grabbed by some
local dictator so the CIA wrote a fake position paper that
“proved” the evil Communists were taking over the government in
that country and Something Had To Be Done! And it was.
The students
rebelled, (the CIA is big on infiltrating and supporting the
volatile student population of target countries) dissidents in exile
were given money and guns and guess what, the evil dictator was
replaced with someone the CIA hand-picked.
Here we have
Guatemala
but now they are aiming at
total disruption of the PRC.
The Company is
behind the uproar in
Tibet
and is fomenting rebellious
thoughts in the
China
’s muslim population. They
feel that
Taiwan
is now a lost cause so the
Station in
Islamabad
is leading the fight to
cause so much internal trouble in
China
that it starts to fall
apart from within.
Under discussion
has been the possible introduction of a laboratory-concocted blight
aimed at the Asian rice crop. Since all of
Asia
depends on rice as a staple
diet item, the sudden (and unexplained) spread of a blight that
ruins the crop would do terrible damage all over
Asia
but especially in
China
.
One of the
Islamabad
reports, a copy of which is
circulating here, explains that
China
is ripe for internal
collapse. She has a huge population which she is having problems
feeding and she has no oil for her burgeoning industry and has to
import all of it.
China
is also now a meat-eating
country and they need American corn to feed their cattle.
The CIA has worked
it so that American farmers are growing corn for Ethanol and not for
export. Oh, there is enough corn
for domestic consumption but interestingly enough, not enough
for export except at a very high price.
They are taking a
leaf from Vladimir Putin’s book. He took Russian oil away from the
pro-US Jewish oligarchs and nationalized it. Now, he controls the
oil and the
U.S.
is getting squeezed. The
CIA is doing the same thing to the Chinese and they reason that if
the food supplies start to dry up there and by some means their oil
imports can be cut back, China will implode and cease to be a
potential threat to the U.S. And if the potentially rebellious
Chinese minorities can be roused up, like their past actions in
arming the Taliban against
Russia
in
Afghanistan
, they have a winner.
With the CIA’s
connections with corporate media, look for more sad horror stories
about
Tibet
.
Tibet
resonates far better than
Dafur does with the American people. They, and Bush, are very upset
about the shift in political winds in
Pakistan
. It looks like assonating
Bhutto did not work they way they wanted it to because all it did
was to guarantee that the wrong people came into power and now our
wings have been clipped there. It is not too difficult to off one
woman but to take out all of the
Pakistan
judicial system and their
legislators is too much even for the CIA. The
Ukraine
operation (taking the
Ukraine
out of Putin’s orbit) was
typical of their style but they waited too long and mis-stepped in
Islamabad
At any rate, look
for more fireworks about the Olympics and know the whys and
wherefores of that situation.”.
Tibet
: Will the
USA
Launch a New Secret War “Under the Roof of the World”?
March 18, 2008
by
Andrei Areshev
iraq-war.ru
The
current unrest in the Tibetan autonomy of the Chinese People’s
Republic (seemingly unexpected) has continued for over a week.
Manifestations organised by Buddhist monks on the occasion of an
anniversary of Tibet’s annexation by China led to mass clashes
with police, violence, fires and robbery. The tragic events
coincided with the regular session of the All-China Assembly of
People’s Representatives, acquiring a dramatic scale and have
already led to deaths, forcing
Beijing
to use active army to crack
down on the riots.
Western
sources report the spread of unrest in the provinces neighbouring
with
Tibet
(in particular
Sichuan
) and mass repressions by the
Chinese authorities, holding them up in an utterly negative aspect.
And here we have an evident parallel with the way western media
covered the activities of the Yugoslav army and police in Kosovo in
1998, immediately before the NATO aggression. Primary sources of
information whose precision is hard to verify, are chiefly Tibetan
émigrés in the neighbouring countries and western human rights
NGOs. For example, according to Thubten Sampkhel, a representative
of the Tibetan “government–in-exile” 80 protestors were killed
and 72 wounded. He says eyewitnesses in
Tibet
who did the actual counting
verified the figures. Official Chinese sources say that 10 people
died. Some pro-Tibetan reports are deliberately over dramatising the
situation. For example there are reports about the involvement of
Chinese troops in mass killings of Tibetans; others say the
“Tibetans in Amdo province have no intention of surrendering and
are resolute to continues protests till the start of this year’s
Olympic Games in Beijing”1.
The
current developments can indeed do great harm to
China
taking place shortly before the 2008 Summer Olympic Games. Demonstrators
in Lhasa have become the gravest challenge to the Chinese rule in
Tibet over the past two decades, raising a worldwide wave of
protests, and holding China up in an unfavourable light on the eve
of the Olympics,” – the Associated Press puts it flatly. However
the current events in that mountainous district have also an even
greater geopolitical significance.
Experts
on events in different continents and nations including
Africa
,
Latin America
,
Myanmar
, the
Central Asia
, the
Middle East
or
Pakistan
constantly stress the
presence of elements of Chinese and American confrontation that is
not always evident but nevertheless not less tense. In particular,
one of the causes of the intervention in
Iraq
and the incessant threats to
Iran
can be accounted for by the
striving to give
China
very poor energy rationing2.
It
can be confidently argued that the present-day troubles faced by
Washington
’s chief geopolitical rival
would be completely taken advantage of with an eye to pushing their
development in a favourable direction. U.S. State Secretary
Condoleezza Rice has already called on
China
to exert “moderation” in
order to overcome the current political crisis in the Tibetan
autonomy. Having said she was sad over the unrest in the Tibetan
administrative centre, Lhasa that followed protests and caused
deaths, Condozleezza Rice said she was worried over reports about
the growing police and army presence in Lhasa, calling on both sides
to refrain from violence. Mrs. State Secretary preferred not to say
that setting shops and buildings on fire and robbery did not fit
well in the picture of peaceful protesting. She rather recalled that
president Gorge W.Bush “has consistently called on
China
’s government to have a
constructive dialogue” with the Dalai Lama, the spiritual leader
of Tibetan Buddhists both directly or negotiating with his
representatives…” On behalf of the
U.S.
administration Mrs. Rice
called on
Beijing
to modify those aspects of
its Tibetan policies that “have led to tension caused by their
impact on the local religion, culture and sources of subsistence.”
It
can be assumed that over the past several years the Tibetan national
movement has become significantly more radical, so
Beijing
would find it hard to see
eye to eye with it. In the oblique way this is evidenced by the
scope and the skill of organisation of protests, as well as the wave
of anti-China manifestations simultaneously sweeping over many
countries from the
United States
and
France
to
Nepal
and
Australia
. The Kosovo independence
issue could not fail to inspire supporters of complete
Tibet
’s independence from
China
either.
Washington
realises this and for the
time being continues to make a stake of the Dalai Lama, the champion
of “peaceful non-violent forms of protest”, some sort of the
“Tibetan Ibrahim Rugova.” The Tibetan spiritual leader enjoys a
wide public support in the West, suffice it to recall his meeting
with G.Bush, Sr. at the ceremony of awarding the Dalai Lama with the
Gold Medal of U.S. Congress in October of 2007.
The
spiritual leader of Tibetan Buddhists has already called for an
international inquiry into
China
’s crackdown. His statement
in Dharamsala3 says: ”The relevant international organisations
should look into the Tibetan situation to clarify its causes.” The
Dalai Lama has called the activities of Chinese authorities as
“cultural genocide.”4
The
Dalai Lama – willingly or not – is effectively preparing
starting grounds for more radical forces that are about to launch an
attack, enjoying political, propaganda and other sorts of support
primarily from forces across the
Atlantic
.
The
U.S.
involvement in the internal
affairs of
Tibet
and its relations with
China
have developed for several
decades. After
China
annexed
Tibet
in 1949 and after the
annexation of Hamand and Amdo provinces in 1956, on the initiative
of the
U.S.
government the CIA started
its “secret war” in the mountains of
Tibet
. In October of 1957, an
aeroplane with no identification marks took off from a field
aerodrome near Dakka carrying the first two Tibetans the CIA had
trained for a month. Landing in the designated location close to
Lhasa
they soon established contacts with the leader of local insurgents. The
Lhasa
uprising started soon after,
and the Dalai Lama fled. In 1958, in total secrecy, over 30 Tibetans
began their training at the
Camp
Hale
base in
Colorado
. Overall, more than 300
Tibetans were trained there. Starting from July, 1958 the CIA began
flying C-130 aircraft from its secret base in
Thailand
, delivering weapons,
ordnance and trained militants. More than 400 tonnes of cargo were
delivered in 1957 through 1960. In one of the sabotage operations by
Tibetans Chief of the Western Tibetan military district was killed,
having on him vitally important documents of the Chinese Communist
party.
Langley
obtained priceless information about
China
’s domestic situation, the
state of its army, the PRC nuclear programmes and the rifts between
Peking
and
Moscow
that began to take place. By
the early 1960s
U.S.
secret services spent an
annual $1.7 million a year in
Tibet
with about $500,000 allocated for the support of 2,100 guerrillas
(including 800 armed militants), mainly based in
Nepal
, and some $180,000 for the
Dalai Lama’s personal needs. When later relations between
Washington
and
Beijing
improved, the activities of
Tibetan agents were temporarily suspended. Tibetans paid a death
toll of 87,000 in crackdowns of uprisings and armed clashes only…
It
is to be noted that the then role of
China
and its economy in world
affairs was not very big, but
Washington
was adamantly pursuing its
policies of interference in Chinese internal affairs in one of its
“problem outskirts.” This has become even more evident in modern
times when the global struggle for influence and resources has
become fiercer than ever. With the Dalai Lama completing his mission
one day, he will be replaced by other people who, with the support
of external forces would attempt to challenge
China
’s national unity as a
state. There will also appear other points of “application of
force” aside from
Tibet
, for example Xiangyang-Uigur
autonomy and
Inner Mongolia
… External policy
complications would not take long to arrive. It can be assumed that
the current situation would dramatically affect relations between
China
and
India
, whom
Washington
is aggressively trying to
draw into its orbit, and more than that.
Unrest
in
Tibet
can unforeseeably echo in
Russia
, especially in the
territories with a sizeable number of Buddhist population. Shows of
support of Tibetan manifestators can happen in Kalmykia, Buriatia
and Tuva. Ch. Budaev, Chairman of “Lamrim” Buddhist community
and the Central Spiritual Buddhist Authority has already expressed
hope that the developments in
Tibet
would lead the way for
democratic changes in the Chinese society. According to him,
democracy in
Russia
was consolidated after the
well-known events of the 1990s that were given broad international
coverage.
“I’d
like to believe,” – Ch.Budaev said, “that the alarming
developments in Tibet we are now witnessing would in the long run
lead to democratisation of the Chinese society.”5
Thus,
attempts of the external forces to propose a Gorbachev-Yeltsin
scenario of
China
’s “democratisation”
directly bring the developments in
Tibet
into the realm of
Russia
’s foreign and domestic
policies.
The
Coming Storm
When
Malthus wrote his essay on population, his second chapter stated
that while the population increased geometrically, food supply only
increased arithmetically. Malthus was right but at the time he
wrote, no one actually believed him. Now, we are experiencing the
truth of his wordy thesis. The following articles deals with the
rapidly accelerating worldwide shortage of food. Countries producing
rice are now keeping as much of it as necessary to feed their own
populations. A hungry people can make revolutions. We have seen food
riots recently in
Haiti
,
Cairo
and
Italy
but the real proof of the Malthusian theory is yet to come.
Wheat-growing countries like the
United States
,
Canada
and the Argentine are facing the question of continuing exporting of
the crop or keeping it to feed its own people. There is no question
what their decisions will be or of what will happen around the
world.
Australia
, once a large wheat grower, has had almost a decade of terrible
drought and is no longer considered a reliable source of supply.
China
has an enormous population, almost no natural resources, especially
oil, and suffers from uncontrolled grown coupled with an equally
uncontrolled capitalism, wedded to a thoroughly corrupt Marxist
government. They must export goods for capital and import food for
political stability. At one point, the ascending graph lines of
population increases intersect with the descending ones of food
production and the results are entirely predictable. BH
Editorial
The
World Food Crisis
April
10, 2008
New
York Times
Most
Americans take food for granted. Even the poorest fifth of
households in the
United States
spend only
16 percent of their budget on food. In many other countries, it is
less of a given. Nigerian families spend 73 percent of their budgets
to eat, Vietnamese 65 percent, Indonesians half. They are in
trouble.
Last
year, the food import bill of developing countries rose by 25
percent as food prices rose to levels not seen in a generation. Corn
doubled in price over the last two years. Wheat reached its highest
price in 28 years. The increases are already sparking unrest from
Haiti
to
Egypt
. Many
countries have imposed price controls on food or taxes on
agricultural exports.
Last
week, the president of the World Bank, Robert Zoellick, warned that
33 nations are at risk of social unrest because of the rising prices
of food. “For countries where food comprises from half to
three-quarters of consumption, there is no margin for survival,”
he said.
Prices
are unlikely to drop soon. The United Nations Food and Agriculture
Organization says world cereal stocks this year will be the lowest
since 1982.
The
United States
and other
developed countries need to step up to the plate. The rise in food
prices is partly because of uncontrollable forces — including
rising energy costs and the growth of the middle class in
China
and
India
. This has
increased demand for animal protein, which requires large amounts of
grain.
But
the rich world is exacerbating these effects by supporting the
production of biofuels. The International Monetary Fund estimates
that corn ethanol production in the
United States
accounted
for at least half the rise in world corn demand in each of the past
three years. This elevated corn prices. Feed prices rose. So did
prices of other crops — mainly soybeans — as farmers switched
their fields to corn, according to the Agriculture Department.
Washington
provides a
subsidy of 51 cents a gallon to ethanol blenders and slaps a tariff
of 54 cents a gallon on imports. In the European Union, most
countries exempt biofuels from some gas taxes and slap an average
tariff equal to more than 70 cents a gallon of imported ethanol.
There are several reasons to put an end to these interventions. At
best, corn ethanol delivers only a small reduction in greenhouse
gases compared with gasoline. And it could make things far worse if
it leads to more farming in forests and grasslands. Rising food
prices provide an urgent argument to nix ethanol’s supports.
Over
the long term, agricultural productivity must increase in the
developing world. Mr. Zoellick suggested rich countries could help
finance a “green revolution” to increase farm productivity and
raise crop yields in
Africa
. But the
rise in food prices calls for developed nations to provide more
immediate assistance. Last month, the World Food Program said rising
grain costs blew a hole of more than $500 million in its budget for
helping millions of victims of hunger around the world.
Industrial
nations are not generous, unfortunately. Overseas aid by rich
countries fell 8.4 percent last year from 2006. Developed nations
would have to increase their aid budgets by 35 percent over the next
three years just to meet the commitments they made in 2005.
They
must not let this target slip. Continued growth of the middle class
in
China
and
India
, the push
for renewable fuels and anticipated damage to agricultural
production caused by global warming mean that food prices are likely
to stay high. Millions of people, mainly in developing countries,
could need aid to avoid malnutrition. Rich countries’ energy
policies helped create the problem. Now those countries should help
solve it.
World
food shortages to stay, riots a risk: FAO
April 9, 2008
by Mayank
Bhardwaj
Reuters
NEW DELHI
(Reuters) - Food riots which have struck
several impoverished countries could spread with shortages and high
prices set to continue for some time, the head of the United
Nation's Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) said.
A
combination of high oil and fuel prices, rising demand for food in a
wealthier Asia, the use of farmland and crops for biofuels, bad
weather and speculation on futures markets have pushed up food
prices, prompting violent protests in a handful of poor states.
Jacques
Diouf, director general of the Rome-based FAO, said on Wednesday
during a trip to
India
that there was a growing risk of social
instability in countries where families spent more than half their
income on food.
"The
problem is very serious around the world due to severe price rises
and we have seen riots in
Egypt
,
Cameroon
,
Haiti
and
Burkina Faso
," he told reporters in
New Delhi
.
Five
people have been killed in a week of demonstrations in
Haiti
over high food prices in the poorest
country in the
Americas
, while unions in the West African nation
of
Burkina Faso
called a general strike over soaring
food and fuel costs.
"There
is a risk that this unrest will spread in countries where 50 to 60
percent of income goes to food," Diouf added.
He
said world cereal stocks were enough to meet demand for eight to 12
weeks, while grain supplies were at their lowest since the 1980s.
"This
is due to higher demand from countries like
India
,
China
, where GDP grows at 8-10 percent and the
increase in income is going to food," Diouf said after meeting
India
's farm minister, Sharad PawarHe said he
was advising governments to invest in irrigation, storage facilities
and rural infrastructure and increase productivity to meet the
challenge of food scarcity.
PRICE SPIRAL
Global
food prices, based on United Nations records, rose 35 percent in the
year to the end of January, markedly accelerating an upturn that
began, gently at first, in 2002.
Since
then, prices have risen 65 percent. In 2007 alone, according to the
FAO's world food index, dairy prices rose nearly 80 percent and
grain 42 percent.
Some
of the world's most populous countries have felt the impact of
higher prices after rice joined a wider rally that has buoyed other
grains like wheat and corn.
Rice
prices in
Thailand
, the world's biggest rice exporter, have
doubled since the start of this year after
India
heavily restricted and then banned the
export of non-basmati rice to ensure it had enough to feed its
people.
In
Manila
, President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo
unveiled a series of measures to boost rice production as troops
armed with M-16 rifles supervised the sale of subsidized grain and
the government threatened to jail hoarders for life.
Pakistan
recently deployed security personnel to
guard its warehouses.
The
FAO in a recent report said
Burkina Faso
,
Cameroon
,
Egypt
,
Indonesia
,
Ivory Coast
,
Mauritania
,
Mozambique
and
Senegal
have seen unrest in the last several
weeks related to food and fuel prices
In
India
, wholesale price inflation hit its
highest in more than three years in March at 7 percent, posing a
headache for the ruling coalition in
Asia
's third-largest economy with elections
for local and national assemblies creeping up.
Price
pressures had been building for several weeks, in large part driven
by foodstuffs, and the government has stepped in with a string of
duty cuts and export restrictions.
Analysts
say fiscal steps were unlikely to roll back prices, and Indian
leaders have said ensuring food security by boosting domestic
production was a priority.
"I
welcome economic growth in
India
and
China
, but I also hope they will invest in
agriculture because these two countries account for 2.2 billion
people out of 6 billion," Diouf said.
(Writing
by Himangshu Watts; Editing by Mark Williams and Jerry Norton)
Bush,
Thine Eye is Everywhere!
Google
has lots to do with intelligence
March 30, 2008
by
Verne Kopytoff
San
Francisco Chronicle
When
the nation's intelligence agencies wanted a computer network to
better share information about everything from al Qaeda to
North Korea
, they turned to a big name
in the technology industry to supply some of the equipment: Google
Inc.
The
Mountain View
company sold the agencies
servers for searching documents, marking a small victory for the
company and its little-known effort to do business with the
government.
"We
are a very small group, and even a lot of people in the federal
government don't know that we exist," said Mike Bradshaw, who
leads Google's federal government sales team and its 18 employees.
The
strategy is part of a broader plan at Google to expand beyond its
consumer roots. Federal, state and local agencies, along with
corporations and schools, are increasingly seen by the company as
lucrative sources of extra revenue.
In
addition to the intelligence agencies, Google's government customers
include the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration,
the U.S. Coast Guard, the National Highway Traffic Safety
Administration, the state of
Alabama
and
Washington
,
D.C.
Many
of the contracts are for search appliances - servers for storing and
searching internal documents. Agencies can use the devices to create
their own mini-Googles on intranets made up entirely of government
data.
Additionally,
Google has had success licensing a souped-up version of its aerial
mapping service, Google Earth. Agencies can use it to plot
scientific data and chart the
U.S.
coastline, for example,
giving ships another tool to navigate safely.
Spy
agencies are using Google equipment as the backbone of Intellipedia,
a network aimed at helping agents share intelligence. Rather than
hoarding information, spies and analysts are being encouraged to
post what they learn on a secure online forum where colleagues can
read it and add comments.
"Each
analyst, for lack of a better term, has a shoe box with their
knowledge," said Sean Dennehy, chief of Intellipedia
development for the CIA. "They maintained it in a shared drive
or a Word document, but we're encouraging them to move those
platforms so that everyone can benefit."
Like Wikipedia
The
system is modeled after Wikipedia, the public online, group-edited
encyclopedia. However, the cloak-and-dagger version is maintained by
the director of national intelligence and is accessible only to the
CIA, FBI, National Security Agency and an alphabet soup of other
intelligence agencies and offices.
Agents
can log in, depending on their clearance, to Intellipedia's three
tiers of service: top secret, secret and sensitive but unclassified.
So far, 37,000 users have established accounts on the network, which
contain 35,000 articles encompassing 200,000 pages, according to
Dennehy.
Google
supplies the computer servers that support the network, as well as
the search software that allows users to sift through messages and
data.
Dennehy
declined to asses the quality of Google's products, but he applauded
the contribution that Intellipedia can make to the government's
work. Whether the network actually leads to better intelligence will
largely depend on agents sharing some of their most important files
and then their colleagues chiming in with incisive commentary -
issues that are out of Google's hands.
Normally,
Google ranks results on its consumer site by using the number of
links to a Web page as a barometer of its importance. Doing so on
Intellipedia isn't as effective because the service lies behind a
firewall and is used by a limited number of people.
Instead,
material gets more prominent placement if it is tagged, or appended
by the network's users, with descriptive keywords.
Because
of the complexities of doing business with the government, Google
uses resellers to process orders on its behalf. Google takes care of
the sales, marketing and management of the accounts.
Conspiracy
theories
Google
is one of many technology vendors vying for government contracts.
A
single deal can be sizable, such as the one Google made with the
National Security Agency, which paid more than $2 million for four
search appliances plus a support agreement, according to a contract
obtained through a Freedom of Information Act request.
However,
the amount is insignificant when measured against Google's overall
revenue of $16.6 billion last year, virtually all of which came from
online advertising.
On
occasion, Google is the target of conspiracy theories from bloggers
who say it is working with spy agencies more closely than simply
selling search equipment.
The
buzz got so loud two years ago that Matt Cutts, who leads Google's
fight against spam Web sites, responded by ridiculing the idea in
his personal blog.
Google's
Bradshaw emphasized that the company sells virtually the same
products to companies as it does to government agencies. Google can
make minor tweaks to comply with government rules about equipment
security, for example, while major customization is handled by
others.
"There
were some wild accusations," Bradshaw said. "But
everything we do with the government is the same as what we do with
our corporate customers."
Former Bush Administration
Lawyer Asked to Testify Before Congress
April
9, 2008
by
Elana Schor
The
Guardian/UK
The
Bush administration lawyer who provided a legal basis for the brutal
interrogation tactics used by the
US
military and
CIA was called to account today by congressional Democrats.
John
Yoo, now a law professor at the
University
of
California
, was asked
to appear before the judiciary committee in the House of
Representatives on May 6 to discuss the legal grounds for the harsh
treatment of al-Qaida suspects.
“The
judiciary committee will look at the legal basis for actions taken
before and during the war and whether we need to write stronger laws
to prevent a future imperial presidency from steamrolling Congress
and the American people,” the Democratic congressman who chairs
the panel, John Conyers, said.
Yoo
previously told Conyers’ aides he was reluctant to testify
publicly about the legal briefs he wrote for the Bush
administration, the congressman said in a letter to his prospective
witness.
But
Conyers reminded Yoo that he has already given an extensive
on-record interview to Esquire magazine for a profile to be
published next month.
“Overall
you have made such extensive public comments on these and related
matters, it is difficult to understand why you would continue to
decline to present your views to the committee,” Conyers wrote to
Yoo.
Yoo
left the office of legal counsel, where he gave legal advice to the
Bush administration, in 2003. Earlier that year, he drafted an
81-page memo giving the Pentagon extensive leeway to harm detainees
during interrogations without fear of legal consequences.
That
memo, which the administration later revoked, was made public for
the first time last week and caused a stir among liberals in
Congress.
In
one section, for example, Yoo said
US
interrogators could maim detainees without fear of prosecution,
depending on the body part that was injured and whether intent to
harm existed.
“Just
because the statute says — that doesn’t mean you have to do
it,” Yoo told Esquire last week. “You’re right, there’s
still the moral question — after you’ve answered the legal
question — whether you should do it at all.”
SECRECY
NEWS
from
the FAS Project on Government Secrecy
Volume
2008, Issue No. 36
April 10,
2008
U.S.
INTELLIGENCE
AGENCIES RETHINK CLASSIFICATION POLICY
U.S.
intelligence
agencies have embarked upon a process to develop a uniform
classification policy and a single classification guide that could
be used by the entire
U.S.
intelligence
community, according to a newly obtained report from the Office of
the Director of National Intelligence.
The
way that intelligence agencies classify information is not only
frustrating to outsiders, as it is intended to be, but it has also
impeded interagency cooperation and degraded agency performance.
In
order to promote improved information sharing and intelligence
community integration, the ODNI undertook a review of classification
policies as a prelude towards establishing a new Intelligence
Community Classification Guide that would replace numerous
individual agency classification policy guides.
The
initial ODNI review, completed in January 2008, identified
fundamental defects in current intelligence classification policy.
"The
definitions of 'national security' and what constitutes
'intelligence' -- and thus what must be classified -- are
unclear," the review team found.
"Many
interpretations exist concerning what constitutes harm or the degree
of harm that might result from improper disclosure of the
information, often leading to inconsistent or contradictory
guidelines from different agencies."
"There
appears to be no common understanding of classification levels among
the classification guides reviewed by the team, nor any consistent
guidance as to what constitutes 'damage,' 'serious damage,'
or
'exceptionally grave damage' to national security... There is wide
variance in application of classification levels."
Among
the recommendations presented in the initial review were that
original classification authorities should specify clearly the basis
for classifying information, e.g. whether the sensitivity derives
from
the
content of the information, or the source of the information, or the
method by which it is analyzed, the date or location it was
acquired, etc. Current policy requires that the classifier be
"able" to describe the basis for classification but not
that he or she in fact do so.
A
copy of the unreleased ODNI report on classification policy was
obtained by Secrecy News.
See
"Intelligence Community Classification Guidance: Findings and
Recommendations Report," January 2008:
http://www.fas.org/sgp/othergov/intel/class.pdf
From
Secrecy News' perspective, the initial ODNI review falls short in
two respects.
First,
it assumes that consistency in classification is intrinsically
desirable and should therefore be imposed by a community-wide
classification guide. But consistency is at most a secondary virtue.
When a classification policy is poorly justified, it is preferable
for it to be inconsistently applied, as in the case of intelligence
budget secrecy (see below).
Second,
the review does not touch upon what is probably the single most
necessary change in intelligence classification policy, namely the
need to narrow the definition of intelligence sources and methods
that require protection. Almost anything can serve as an
intelligence source or method, including a subscription to the daily
newspaper. But not every intelligence source or method requires or
deserves classification or other protection from disclosure.
STATE
DEPARTMENT REVEALS 2009 INTELLIGENCE BUDGET REQUEST
The
U.S. State Department's Bureau of Intelligence and Research (INR) is
among the most highly regarded members of the U.S. Intelligence
Community. Not coincidentally, it is also among the most open and
accessible.
In
particular, it is one of the only Intelligence Community
organizations that regularly publishes its budget. (The FBI also
discloses much of its intelligence spending.)
Thus,
the recent 2009 State Department budget justification book projects
a 2009 INR budget of $59.8 million for a staff of 313 persons. The
ten-page 2009 budget justification for INR may be found here:
http://www.fas.org/irp/agency/inr/fy2009just.pdf
This
would be unremarkable except for the fact that INR's budget
disclosure policy deviates from the norm of
U.S.
intelligence
classification policy, in which most budget information is
automatically classified. Even some intelligence organizations that
are smaller and less influential than INR insist on classifying
their budgets.
For
more than a decade, the Department of Energy Office of Intelligence
published its detailed budget each year. But under pressure from CIA
(so I was told), DOE began withholding its intelligence budget
information in 2004. The last reported figure for DOE intelligence
was $39.8 million in FY 2004 (Secrecy News,
02/07/05
).
If
consistency in classification policy were to prevail throughout the
U.S.
intelligence
community, as the Director of National Intelligence has recommended,
then State Department intelligence might be expected to follow DOE
intelligence into pointless, unnecessary secrecy.
CORRECTION
ON COLLAPSE OF BEE COLONIES
A
Science Daily story on the causes of the declining honey bee
population that was cited yesterday in Secrecy News was from April
2007, not April 2008. Though interesting, it was not news.
The
Coming Death of the Hedge Funds
March 31, 2008
by- Joseph Checkler
The Wall Street
Journal(:
"
New York
activist hedge fund Pardus Capital Management LP is halting
investor redemptions indefinitely at a time when many of its
holdings are plummeting in value… Pardus, which doesn’t use
leverage, is down 40% from its high-water mark in early 2007, said a
person with knowledge… ‘The actions we have taken will allow us
to protect the funds and their investors from the external
short-term pressure of the broader financial markets and focus on
realizing value on our portfolio companies for investors over an
extended period of time,’ Pardus said."
April 1, 2008
by
Tom Cahill and Katherine Burton
Bloomberg
"Stock
hedge funds, unsure about which direction the markets would move,
sat on a record amount of cash as the industry headed for its
biggest quarterly decline in almost six years. Equity managers, who
oversee about one-third of the $1.9 trillion in hedge funds, held an
estimated $90 billion of cash in January, a hoard that dropped to
$64.8 billion the next month, according to data compiled by Merrill
Lynch analyst Mary Ann Bartels."
April 3, 2008
by James Mackintosh
Financial Times
“Hedge
funds are still reeling after banks unexpectedly pulled credit lines
and demanded more security against loans, forcing firesales and
heavy losses. Now they face a new threat: investors are abandoning
them, raising the risk that the funds will have to sell assets at
any price to raise the cash to meet withdrawals. So far redemptions
are mainly in out-of-favour sectors such as credit funds, small-cap
specialists and event-driven funds, which include activists, along
with poor performers unexpectedly hurt by the credit squeeze. But a
series of big funds have already been forced to react, restricting
withdrawals or restructuring, and more are thought to be considering
changes. ‘There are two ways you get squeezed running a hedge
fund,’ says one large investor in the industry. ‘One is that you
can’t get finance from your prime broker. The other is that the
clients take their money away and you can’t get enough liquidity
[cash] to meet the redemptions.’"
Comment: Most
hedge funds are Ponze schemes. If an investor reads this and doubts
it, try and get your money out. If the fund agrees at once, don’t
worry but probably (and this is more prevalent now) the investor
will get all kinds of weasel-worded paper which will boil down to a
refusal. They can’t give back what isn’t there, can they? BH
In
U.S.
, Metal Theft Plagues
Troubled Neighborhoods
April 8, 2008
by Christopher Maag
New York Times
CLEVELAND
— Metal scrappers have
attacked churches and ransacked homes in this Midwestern city,
leaving entire neighborhoods uninhabitable.
Saint
Theodosius Orthodox Cathedral here lost its insurance after a thief
stole copper panels from the roof years ago. Three churches in
Cleveland Heights
have been stripped of
copper gutters. And in the last few months, three churches in the
North Collinwood
neighborhood were stripped
of copper downspouts.
“Our
neighborhoods are being pillaged, not by Vikings or Goths, but by
modern-day barbarians,” said Mike Polensek,
North Collinwood
’s City Council member.
Even manhole covers and sewer drains are being stolen out of streets
to be sold as scrap metal, Mr. Polensek said.
Houses,
however, are the greatest targets of commodity scavengers in the
United States
. Neighborhoods depopulated
by the rising tide of foreclosures make easy targets.
So
many houses have been stripped of siding and copper pipes that
neighborhoods must be abandoned and turned into green spaces, said
Jim Rokakis, treasurer for
Cuyahoga
County
, which includes
Cleveland
. “We have to pull
out,” he said. “There’s nothing left.”
It
is common for home builders and remodelers here to erect signs on
plywood that read “All PVC pipes, no copper,” indicating a house
has less expensive plastic piping.
In
the last six months, the police in the city of
Cleveland Heights
have arrested two groups
of scrappers who used government foreclosure lists to plot which
houses to sack.
Scrap
metal thefts began to soar
12
to 18 months ago.
“There’s a direct correlation between the price of commodities
and the number of metal thefts,” said Bruce Savage, spokesman for
the
Institute
of
Scrap Recycling
Industries
.
The
institute received 174 reports from the police around the country
regarding metal thefts from Jan. 1 to March 28 of this year, a sharp
increase over the period in 2007, and the actual number of thefts is
much higher, Mr. Savage said.
Copper
pipes, among the most commonly stolen items, are selling for just
over $3 a pound. The local police report bronze urns taken from
gravestones and long sections of aluminum bleachers stolen from high
school stadiums.
Catalytic
converters in vehicles are also popular targets because they contain
platinum, which this month sold for an average of $1,900 an ounce.
US
mortgage crisis to cost $945
billion worldwide: IMF
April 8, 2008
AFP
WASHINGTON (AFP) - - The International
Monetary Fund said Tuesday the worldwide losses stemming from the US
subprime mortgage crisis could hit 945 billion dollars as the impact
spreads in the global economy.
The IMF, in a particularly stark report,
said that falling US housing prices and rising delinquencies on the
residential mortgage market could lead to losses of 565 billion
dollars.
That, combined with other categories of
loans originated and securities issued in the
United States
related to commercial real estate, the consumer credit market and
corporations "increases aggregate potential losses to about 945
billion dollars," it said.
"The crisis is spreading beyond the
US
subprime market -- namely to the prime residential and commercial
real estate markets, consumer credit, and the low- to high-grade
corporate credit markets," the IMF said in releasing its
semiannual Global Financial Stability Report.
While the
US
remains the epicenter, "financial institutions in other
countries have also been affected, reflecting the same overly benign
global financial conditions and to varying degrees -- weaknesses in
risk management systems and prudential supervision."
It was the first time the multilateral
institution has made an official estimate of the global losses
suffered by banks and other financial institutions in the credit
squeeze that began eight months ago in the
United States
, amid rising defaults on subprime, or high-risk, home loans.
The staggering 945 billion dollar estimate
of losses, made in March, represents roughly 142 dollars per person
worldwide and represents four percent of the 23.21-trillion-dollar
credit market.
The IMF said that global banks likely will
shoulder about half of the losses -- at 440 billion to 510 billion
dollars.
Last month, ratings agency Standard &
Poor's estimated global banking firms would likely write off 285
billion dollars in various securities linked to US subprime real
estate, with more than half the losses already recognized. Some
analysts have put the figure higher for the subprime market and
related losses.
"Leading indicators point to a
tightening of credit conditions across many economic
activities," Jaime Caruana, head of the IMF's Monetary and
Capital Markets Department, said at a news conference.
Caruana said the losses "suggest a
potentially large impact on
US
economic growth," and that
Europe
may also see tightening conditions and slowing credit growth under
the global financial strain.
The IMF releases its biannual World
Economic Outlook on Wednesday and already has said it would slash a
half percentage point off its forecast of 2008 global economic
growth, to 3.7 percent.
The Global Financial Stability Report
cautioned that loss estimates were imperfect and could go higher.
The unusually precise and harsh report
comes ahead of the IMF and the World Bank spring meetings Saturday
and Sunday in
Washington
.
The IMF, whose core mission is to promote
global financial stability, said there was "a collective
failure to appreciate the extent of leverage taken on by a wide
range of institutions -- banks, monoline insurers,
government-sponsored entities, hedge funds -- and the associated
risks of a disorderly unwinding.
"It is now clear that the current
turmoil is more than simply a liquidity event, reflecting
deep-seated balance sheet fragilities and weak capital bases, which
means its effects are likely to be broader, deeper, and more
protracted," it said.
The report criticizes the "excessive
risk-taking" and "weak underwriting" undertaken by
under-capitalized institutions.
The IMF recommended a range of measures to
address issues raised by the crisis, including better coordination
between central banks, improved transparency from financial
institutions and reform of ratings systems.
|